Breaking News: Burnley boss Vincent Kompany Fires Hot On VAR following controversy during Tottenham v Liverpool game.
Vincent Kompany believes football must work to make VAR better following this weekend’s officiating controversy.
During Liverpool’s 2-1 loss to Tottenham on Saturday, the technology was unable to fix an erroneous offside determination.
PGMOL, the organization that oversees referees, has stated that it was “a significant human error” that caused the decision to rule against Luis Diaz’s goal.
Still images of the incident showed Tottenham defender Cristian Romero playing Diaz onside.
When the game was tied but Jurgen Klopp’s team was down to 10 men after Curtis Jones’ contentious dismissal as a result of VAR intervention, the disallowed goal was scored.
For the remainder of the weekend, the VAR officials were relieved of their duties.
Liverpool deemed the explanation “unacceptable” and demanded a “review with full transparency” in a statement.
The Reds also said they will “explore the range of options available given the clear need for escalation and resolution”.
Burnley have been on the wrong end of a VAR call themselves this season when Lyle Foster’s strike was ruled out during the 1-1 draw against Nottingham Forest, when Sander Berge was harshly adjudged to have handled the ball during the build-up.
When asked if he’s lost trust in the technology ahead of Tuesday night’s rearranged fixture against Luton Town, Kompany said: “I think we’ve gone down a road now where this is it, we’ve got to make this the best we can.
“It’s tough because we’ve also had the same situation with VAR this season and when you’re on the wrong end of it, it really hurts.
“But I still think the approach of being open about this…I want to maybe discuss the other side of it, which is every time you make a decision in this country you get an extensive report about it.
be open about it, admitting to mistakes and apologising for it and as much as you have no understanding when it happens to you, I still think it’s the right way to go about it.
“From my side, I prefer to talk about us making it the best we can and getting it right, understanding what we need for football.
Rather than pointing out individuals because they’re doing the best they can and we all obviously make mistakes.”
Read Next:
The VAR Review: What went wrong for Luis Diaz’s offside goal
Video Assistant Referee causes controversy every week in the Premier League, but how are decisions made, and are they correct?
After each weekend, we take a look at the major incidents, to examine and explain the process both in terms of VAR protocol and the Laws of the Game.
In this week’s VAR Review: What went wrong in the VAR room to disallow Luis Diaz’s goal for Liverpool at Tottenham Hotspur, Curtis Jones’ red card, a missed penalty award for Brentford and the rest of the weekend’s events.
Possible offside overturn: Diaz goal
What happened: Mohamed Salah played Luis Díaz through on goal in the 34th minute, and the forward produced a superb strike across goalkeeper Guglielmo Vicario to score.
However, the offside flag immediately went up for offside, and the VAR, Darren England, began a check. (watch here.)
VAR decision: Goal, incorrectly communicated.
Possible offside overturn: Diaz goal
What happened: Mohamed Salah played Luis Díaz through on goal in the 34th minute, and the forward produced a superb strike across goalkeeper Guglielmo Vicario to score.
However, the offside flag immediately went up for offside, and the VAR, Darren England, began a check. (watch here.)
VAR decision: Goal, incorrectly communicated.
VAR review: How do you get a decision both right and disastrously wrong at the same time?
It’s a question that refs chief Howard Webb and his leadership team will have to answer in the coming days and take steps to ensure an inexcusable mistake of this magnitude can never happen again. It’s the biggest error the Premier League has seen.
England and the assistant VAR, Dan Cook, were swiftly both stood down from duties in fixtures on Sunday and Monday, but that kind of action is of no comfort to Jurgen Klopp and his Liverpool players. Both are unlikely to be selected in the upcoming matchweeks.
The VAR made one very simple but inexplicable error: He lost concentration and got the on-field decision incorrect when completing the check.
When the VAR looked at the position of Diaz, it quickly became apparent that he was very clearly onside.
It was checked with the use of the offside lines in the background — you see proof of this on the VAR feed when the technology operator zooms in to place them.
And this is where it starts to go wrong. England somehow now thinks he is checking a goal, rather than a disallowed goal (he cannot see the overlay shown on TV and in the stadium).
If he was confirming an overturn he would lock in the offside lines, but as he now thinks the on-field decision is “goal,” there’s no prerequisite to do so when the onside is an obvious one.
England cleared the review so quickly and with such confidence he didn’t even get the opinion of the assistant VAR. Perhaps that was the issue, it was such a regulation “onside” decision that he thought he would wrap it up. And he said “check complete.”
Perhaps the decision was so straightforward that England lost focus and forgot what the on-field decision actually was, because by saying those two words, he’s telling the on-field officials their decision is correct. Rather than clearing the goal, he was mistakenly telling the referee the offside call was correct.
Semi-automated offside technology, which Premier League clubs chose not to introduce this season, would have made no difference in this situation because the error is the communication with the referee. England correctly identified that Diaz was onside.
Phil Bentham was brought in from rugby league last season as VAR coach specifically to work on communication. Lessons will need to be learned about the process of “check complete.”
What happened next came so fast, there was no time to react within protocol. Just two seconds after the VAR has said “check complete,” Spurs took the free kick, which creates a cut-off point.
Nothing can be reviewed after a restart. (This doesn’t apply to penalties awarded for offences before the half-time or final whistle, as play was still active at the time of the offence.)
Leave a Reply